Site Explorer
Keyword tool
Google Algorithm Changes
There is no need to stress more the fact that Google has just made an innovative update: Penguin 4.0 – a real-time, granular algorithm update that allows both real-time penalties and incredibly quick recoveries. However, with such a big controversy around this update, what we need to dwell on more are case studies and analyses in order to have the best understanding of the latest Penguin phenomenon.
As (we hope) you’re already used to, at cognitiveSEO we are highly interested in research but not just for the sake of it, but with the purpose of understanding. The Penguin 4.0 update is in our sights now and this is why we’ve run some analysis to see what the algorithm is bringing new to the table. Therefore, grab a cup of coffee and take a look at these fresh new findings.
1. After 3 Years of Almost No Traffic Penguin 4.0 Brought a 370% Traffic Boost
SmartFares (smartfares.com) is a travel reservation service activating on the market since 2006, specialized in providing affordable travelling fares available in the marketplace. Nothing unheard so far. Yet, what is special about this website, and the reason we are looking into it, is that their rankings “rise and fall”.
smartfares.com
As we take a look at the screenshot above, we can easily spot some high Google updates activity, but 2 of these updates will probably remain in the history of this website. The first algorithm update that impacted smartfares.com is the Penguin 2.0, somewhere around October 2013. They had a big drop then and it seems that they have never recovered ever since. Until this fall.
The Penguin 4.0 brought the highest visibility from 2013 until now.
The harvest season came with good news for this travelling website as in the same October, 3 years later from the Penguin penalty, they had the biggest increase in visibility from 2013 until now. Maybe Penguin 4.0 really is “the nicest update” as Google representatives mentioned, at least for these guys.
As we take a look at the “winning keywords” for them, we spot some impressive ranking position increases. What is even more interesting is that all these increases are affecting highly commercial keywords: 77 positions up for “cheap rental cars” or 82 positions up for “last minute airfaire”. Highly commercial keywords are being propelled at the very top. Which made us really curious on how the smartfares.com’ link profile looks like.
It’s really difficult to try making anything, without having the proper tools at your disposal. Even if we’re talking about a dog cage, repairing a bicycle or making an in-depth research on digital marketing, when having the proper means at our disposal, things get easier. In our case, having the possibility to run an automated unnatural link detection on any website we wanted, along with checking their Search Visibility, made this analysis possible.
After we ran the unnatural link detection, we were not surprised to see that more than 50% of their total links are unnatural. And when taking a closer look at their unnatural links, we notice that it’s mostly about links placed in short paragraph of text, web directories, group of links, domains with no authority and thin content, etc.
In this context, the obvious question pops out:
Why did Penguin 4.0 recover a website with such a high unnatural profile?
What most likely happened is that smartfares.com have submitted a disavow sometimes in the past. They were down for three whole years now and they were suddenly recovered.
Our supposition is that even if their unnatural links are still live, they must have submitted a disavow and Google simply doesn’t take those links into consideration when ranking this website. Their unnatural links are still live but they simply don’t count in the ranking algorithm.
We do not think that Penguin 4.0 is in a Thanksgiving mood, recovering sites that haven’t made sustained recovery efforts.
Therefore, what Penguin Real Time made for these guys was to rank them and boost them up according to their OK links only. It’s a great recovery for smartfares.com and an interesting case study for all of us to look at.
2. Impressive Penguin 4.0 Recovery for a Big Online Store
There is a quote of the novelist Robert Ferro I particularly like in the present context; it goes like this: The key to life was rearranging the furniture. lafurniturestore.com, as its name states, is a furniture store that got recently “rearranged”, but not in the typical way of moving the sofa near the window and the coffee table in its place.
The sort of rearrangement this website got came from Google Penguin 4.0 that boosted this website’s ranks after a penalty that occurred back in 2013.
lafurniturestore.com
And if you think that the search visibility increase is not that high when looking at a 5 year chart, when taking a pek at a micro level, we can see that lafurniturestore.com’s visibility has an impressive spike after the latest Google update.
lafurniturestore.com
Also, when looking at their top ranking keywords, we ca see that they’re doing pretty well for highly competitive keywords. With seven keywords ranking number one, of which there are keywords with high search volume and traffic index, it seems like lafurniturestore.com is back in the business after almost three years of absence.
However, when looking at their link profile unnaturalness, we encounter the same unnatural link patter that we did for the example above with smartfares.com.
High number of unnatural links, high number of commercial keywords and most of the links being placed in web directories, short paragraphs of text and group of links.
Just like before, our supposition is that lafurniturestore.com submitted a disavow file in the past and now, with the newest update, they are enjoying the fruits of their labor.
3. A 320% Increase in Traffic for a Penalized Auto Related Site
Buyautoparts.com, a business headquartered in California that has sold car parts for over 20 years, seems to have experience not only in sales but also when it comes to Google Penalties. Being hit by a Penguin 2.0, the new real time update brought good news for them this fall, as they are having the biggest rank boost since their 2013 penalty.
They seem to have had some rankings fluctuations in the past due to some other algorithm updates, yet, none of them was so significant as the boost brought by the Penguin 4.0 update.
buyautoparts.com
4. Penguin 2.0 Penalty Removed by Penguin 4.0 – Huge Traffic Recovery
The French website proxiconfort.fr, an online appliances store, seems to be enjoying a great boost in rankings due to the latest Google update.
proxiconfort.fr
Yet, even if their link profile doesn’t seem to be the most natural one, with lots of links being placed in web directories or group of links, the French appliance website seem to benefit from the Penguin Real Time update.
As in the previous cases, it’s very likely that this website might have submitted a disavow file and Google now ranks the website based on the natural links only, ignoring the unnatural links even if they are still live.
5. Penguin 4.0 Recovery for a Website Penalized 4 Years Ago
As we’ve analyzed websites coming from such a variety of domains and countries, e-autoparts.pl, a Polish business specialized in selling car parts, reached our analysis due to the Penguin 4.0 recovery they recently benefited from. e-autoparts.pl had a penalty back in 2012 and since then, the site never returned to its glory until this month.
It seems that the Penguin 4.0 had a big impact on this website, giving it its ranks back, after more than four years.
e-autoparts.pl
6. Pharmacy Website Got Huge Traffic Boost After Penguin 4.0
There have been some debates in the past whether Google Penguin impacts only English queries or not. Websites penalties regardless of the language there are in, have put an end to these debates. With the newest Penguin update on the table, we took a look into some German websites to see whether the real time algorithm has influenced in any ways their rankings.
As we look at the omp-apotheke.de’s search visibility we can easily see that the Penguin 4.0 recovered this website from a penalty that hit them more than 3 years ago.
omp-apotheke.de
If from our previous analysis we figured that out, even if the recoveries occurred, the websites still had a lot of unnatural links live, in this case, it seems that omp-apotheke.de managed somehow to remove the links that might have attracted their penalty. Their link profile, with a few exceptions, is looking quite natural, with around 90% of the total links being OK.
7. German Online Casino – Huge Visibility Increase Due to Penguin 4.0
Have you ever wondered if the doubling strategy at roulette now works? Or whether you can beat the Blackjack dealer with the method of card counting? No worries, we haven’t reoriented our filed of interest, we were just quoting some of the questions placed on the online casino casinoverdiener.com, a website taken into consideration for our Penguin 4.0 Recoveries case study.
After a Penguin update hit them a couple of years ago, it seems that the real time Google update brought some real added value to their business, boosting their rankings.
casinoverdiener.com
8. Impressive Penguin 4.0 Recovery for an Online Furniture Shop
lifestyle4living.de is an online furniture shop that is facing a great recovery after a three year penalty.
lifestyle4living.de
There are still a lot of aspects to investigate when it comes to Penguin 4.0. Yet, we are glad that we can share such analysis with you, case studies from which all of us can learn a lot.
As for the future, our task is not to foresee it, but to enable it.
And this is why, come what may, in order to prevent any penalty, you need the right tool to help you:
- Know how your link profile looks like, as well as your competitors’
- Get rid or Disavow your Unnatural links as they appear
- Regularly monitor your backlink profile
- Be alerted as you as unnatural link activity is spotted within your website.
Thank you for the great article. I use CognitiveSEO and am seeing the same increase from Penguin 4.0 and recovery. I am glad Google is finally integrating the disavow file.
glad to hear Matt. I suppose it’s about the Weddingmuseum dot com site?
congrats!!!
Love the increase as it can be seen here
http://explorer.cognitiveseo.com/?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.weddingmuseum.com&m=U*#section/4
That’s it! Thanks for sharing.
Glad you liked the article, Matt! It’s nice, indeed to see some recoveries.
I’ve seen a lot of people talking about how the disavow tool doesn’t work any more and I tend to agree. But those are some great recoveries!
I disagree with the fact that the disavow tool does not work anymore. Google’s representatives said several times that the disavow tool is still required if you have a manual penalty or if you have a highly unnatural link profile or if you think Google should really take in consideration that some links that you flag are unnatural and discount them from the algo.
As you saw these recoveries seem to be highly likely related to using the disavow tool as most of the sites still have a highly unnatural link profile.
I think also patience needs to come into play with Penguin 4. I would expect Google has devalued a lot of spammy/poor sites prior to the update, but purely on a crawling basis, so it is reasonable to anticipate a relatively slow crawling process. Which of course will slow down the Penguin refresh for that site.
indeed patience was required. Some sites were hit in 2013 and recovered just now. pretty painful to say the least.
Imagine if you take no action to protect or recover your site than most likely nothing will happen.
Great article and some great early data . We have seen some spammy competitors of ours move down since penguin 4 which is great news, but we have only seen this happen in desktop search not mobile that remains unchanged. Has anyone else noticed this ?
If i use footer backlink its like unnatural profile?
Footer links created with the intent of manipulating the SERPs are considered unnatural. Add NOFOLLOW to them to be on the safe side of things.
Still waiting. Submitted some disavow files for a few sites a few months before p4 so guess they should have been taken into consideration now?
Your case studies and proofs just convince me that disavow can work.
Ive read a few posts which said it wouldn’t.
But your results are pretty amazing.
I just like to say thank you for such an informative and well put together article. Keep up the good work!
Hi cognitiveseo, I’ve been reading your blog posts for several days now and I am really loving it.
I am trying to recover from the sudden fall of my website ranking, I don’t know what got wrong but I am optimistic that I will overcome it. I will just keep on reading articles like this and hopefully will be able to get some tips on how will I fix my site. Thanks and more power!